Home  /  Medicare  /  Medicare Options Compared

Medicare resource

Supplement or Advantage? See them side by side.

Original Medicare, a Medicare Supplement and Medicare Advantage, compared on what you pay, which doctors you can see and how easy it is to change later.

What we compare

Three ways to have Medicare

Cost each month

Premiums

Cost when you get care

Copays

Doctors and travel

Networks

Changing later

Windows

Side by side

Understanding your Medicare coverage options.

Everyone starts with Parts A and B. You can keep them as they are, add a Supplement and a drug plan, or choose a Medicare Advantage plan instead.

Original Medicare

Original + Supplement

Medicare Advantage

Who runs it

Original Medicare

The federal government

Original + Supplement

Medicare pays first, then a private insurer pays its share

Medicare Advantage

A private insurer approved by Medicare

Each month

Original Medicare

The Part B premium

Original + Supplement

Part B, plus the Supplement and Part D premiums. Usually the highest of the three

Medicare Advantage

Part B, plus the plan premium. Some plans have none

When you get care

Original Medicare

Deductibles, then about 20%

Original + Supplement

Little or nothing, depending on the plan letter

Medicare Advantage

Copays and coinsurance set by the plan

Yearly limit

Original Medicare

None

Original + Supplement

Little left to limit. Plans K and L have one

Medicare Advantage

Yes, every plan has one

Doctors and hospitals

Original Medicare

Any that take Medicare, nationwide

Original + Supplement

Any that take Medicare, nationwide

Medicare Advantage

Usually a network near home

Specialists

Original Medicare

No referral needed

Original + Supplement

No referral needed

Medicare Advantage

HMOs usually need a referral. PPOs usually don’t

Prescriptions

Original Medicare

Not included. Add Part D

Original + Supplement

A separate Part D plan

Medicare Advantage

Usually built in

Dental, vision, hearing

Original Medicare

Very little

Original + Supplement

Not included. Add a dental and vision plan

Medicare Advantage

Often some routine benefits

Changing later

Original Medicare

Join Advantage in set windows

Original + Supplement

Move to Advantage each fall

Medicare Advantage

Going back to a Supplement may mean health questions

Which might suit you

The right choice depends entirely on your needs.

Most people end up choosing between a Supplement with a drug plan and a Medicare Advantage plan. Here’s who each one tends to suit.

Original Medicare + Supplement

Might suit you if…

  • You want to keep seeing any doctor who takes Medicare
  • You’d rather pay more each month and little at the doctor
  • You travel, or spend part of the year in another state
  • You expect regular visits, tests or treatment

Medicare Advantage

Might suit you if…

  • Your doctors are in the plan’s network
  • You want a lower premium and don’t mind copays
  • You’d like drug, dental or vision benefits in one plan
  • You get most of your care close to home

Original Medicare on its own has no yearly limit and no drug coverage, so most people add one or the other. We’ll compare both for you.

Before you choose

Five questions that point the way.

We work through these with every client before comparing a single plan. Your answers usually make the choice clear.

01

Is there a doctor or hospital you won’t give up?

Advantage plans use networks. Check yours is in it before anything else.

If yes: Leans Supplement

02

Do you travel or live somewhere else part of the year?

A Supplement works the same in every state. Most networks stay local.

If yes: Leans Supplement

03

Would you rather pay less each month and pay as you go?

Lower premiums usually mean copays when you get care.

If yes: Leans Advantage

04

Do you want dental, vision or hearing in the same plan?

Many Advantage plans include some. A Supplement doesn’t.

If yes: Leans Advantage

05

Do you expect frequent care or ongoing treatment?

A Supplement keeps those costs low and predictable.

If yes: Leans Supplement

Changing your mind later

What you choose now isn’t forever.

Medicare has set times to make changes. Moving to Advantage is easy. Moving back to a Supplement can be harder, so it helps to know the windows.

Oct 15 – Dec 7

Annual Open Enrollment

Switch between Original Medicare and Advantage, change Advantage plans, or change your Part D plan. Changes start January 1.

Jan 1 – Mar 31

Advantage Open Enrollment

Already in an Advantage plan? You can make one change: another Advantage plan, or back to Original Medicare with Part D.

First 12 months

Your Advantage trial right

Joined Advantage when you first got Medicare? Leave within a year and you can usually buy a Supplement without health questions.

Each birthday

Virginia and Maryland

If you already have a Supplement, the birthday rule lets you change carriers without health questions, within the rule’s limits.

Comparing your options

Before you decide.

No. A Supplement only works with Original Medicare. If you join an Advantage plan, a Supplement won’t pay any of its costs.

Some plans have a $0 premium, but you still pay your Part B premium, plus copays and coinsurance when you get care, up to the plan’s yearly limit.

It depends on your doctors, prescriptions, travel and budget. We specialize in Supplements, and we’re happy to compare Advantage plans on request.

You may need to find a new doctor or pay more. Networks can change each year, so we check yours every fall.

No. We compare plans from the companies we represent. For all of your options, contact Medicare.gov, 1‑800‑MEDICARE or your State Health Insurance Assistance Program.

Still deciding?

Let’s weigh it with your doctors in mind.

Bring your doctors and prescriptions. We’ll show you how each option would work for you, in plain numbers.

✓ Your doctors

✓ Your prescriptions

✓ Where you spend the year